Restaurant Menu


Cold Water Oysters

East and West Coast oysters our selection changes daily shucked to order & served on crushed ice with cocktail sauce, horseradish, lemon & island Park Mignonette  2.50 each

Gulf Oysters on the Half Shell

1/2 Dozen Market $, Full Dozen Market $, Steamed add 1.00

Clams on the Half Shell

1/2 Dozen 6.95, Dozen 11.95, Steamed add 1.00

Peel & Eat Shrimp

1/2 Pound or Pound, Market $

Oyster Moscow (6)

Freshly shucked topped with horseradish, sour cream  & caviar  Market $

Shrimp Cocktail (5)

Peeled jumbo shrimp 14.95

Florida Keys Stone Crab Claws

Medium or large served chilled & cracked with Key Lime mustard sauce (seasonal) Market $

Seafood Tower

Chilled 1/2 dozen oysters & clams on the 1/2 shell, 1 pound of peel & eat shrimp and 1pound medium stone crab claws Market $


Baked Key Lime Garlic Oysters

Topped with garlic butter, bread crumbs & parmesan cheese 12.95

Baked B.B.Q. Oysters

Topped with bacon and  parmesan cheese 12.95

Baked Oyster Rockefeller

Baked with spinach, onions, parmesan cheese and Pernod liquor 14.95

The Island’s Oyster Combo

Two each of our baked oysters 14.95

Beer Steamed Shrimp

1/2 Pound or Pound, Market $

Itty Bitty Steamers

Little neck clams with drawn butter 10.95

Clams Casino

Topped with onions, red & green bell peppers, garlic & bacon 10.95


Conch Fritters

Loads if conch 10.95

Fried Calamari

Flash fried  with banana peppers, onions, tomato, cilantro & key lime mustard aioli 10.95

Mango Crab Cakes

Loaded with blue crab, pan seared golden brown and served with key lime mustard sauce 12.95

Tuna Tataki

Sesame seared Ahi tuna with wasabi, pickled ginger, seaweed salad & sesame ginger vinaigrette 14.95

Buffalo Shrimp

Tossed in hot pepper sauce served with ranch dressing 12.95

Spinach Crab Dip

Served with crustinis 10.95

Conch Ceviche

Tender pieces of marinated conch with tomato, cilantro, diced onion, red & green peppers in key lime vinaigrette. Served with tortilla chips 13.95

Lobster Eggs Roll

Two egg rolls filled with lobster, roasted red peppers, corn, scallions, jack & cheddar cheese, served with mango chutney 9.95

Smoked Fish Dip

Fresh fish blended with cream cheese, onions, spices and Key Lime juice. served with an assortment of crackers 8.95


Always homemade with the freshest ingredients  Cup 4.25 ~Bowl 5.50

Conch Chowder

Island style with just a little kick

Island She Krab

Our version of this classic

Soup Of The Day

Made fresh daily


Choice of Ranch, Thousand Island, Honey Mustard, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Balsamic Vinaigrette, & Blue Cheese

House Salad

A mixture of fresh lettuce & garden vegetables  Small 4.25 ~ Large 6.95

Chef’s Salad

The Island’s version of the classic. Our large house salad with grilled chicken, shrimp, crab & cheese 16.95

Seared  Ahi Tuna Carpaccio

Sliced thin over mixed greens, pineapple, blue cheese, tomatoes, artichokes, cucumbers, onions, pickled ginger, wasabi, seaweed salad served with ginger teriyaki vinaigrette 21.95


Crisp romaine lettuce with Caesar dressing, parmesan cheese & croutons. Small 5.95 ~ Large 8.50

Cajun Chicken Salad

Cajun spiced fried chicken breast over greens with garden vegetables with monterey & cheddar cheeses 11.95

Island Spinach Salad

Topped with mushrooms, hard boiled egg,  croutons & bacon served with a hot bacon raspberry vinaigrette 13.95

Add to any Large Salad Additional:

Grilled or Fried Shrimp 7.95
Grilled Chicken 4.95
Grilled Dolphin 8.95
Grilled Grouper 10.95

Blackened Items Add 1.00


Chicken Quesadilla

Quesadilla with grilled chicken, green chili sauce, sautéed onions, served with sour cream, salsa & guacamole 10.50

Shrimp Quesadilla

Grilled shrimp with monterey jack & cheddar cheese, green chili sauce, scallions with sour cream, guacamole & pineapple salsa 15.95


Fresh corn tortilla smothered with monterey jack & cheddar cheese with tomato salsa 7.95

Macho Chicken Nachos

Grilled with tomatoes, olives, black beans, jalapenos, scallions. smothered  in cheese with salsa, sour cream & guacamole 12.95

Key West Grilled Shrimp Tacos

Soft tacos with cabbage, green chili, sour cream, tomatoes, jack & cheddar with tortilla chips 13.95

Baja Fish Tacos

Soft tacos with lightly fried Mahi, cabbage, tomato, cilantro, jalapeños and a sour cream salsa, served with rice & black beans 12.95


All wraps served with chef’s rice & black beans

Fried Mahi Mahi

With tomatoes, onions, lettuce & tarter sauce  12.95

Pistachio Chicken

Spring greens, tomatoes & honey mustard  13.95

Mexicano Chicken

Rice, black beans, scallions, tomato, jack cheese, sour cream & guacamole 12.95

Grilled Chicken Caesar

Romaine lettuce, tomato, parmesan cheese, Caesar dressing 12.95


Caribbean Special

Pan seared grouper with pineapple salsa, black beans and chef’s rice  20.95

Stuffed Shrimp

Key West Pink Gold Shrimp stuffed with mango crabmeat stuffing baked and topped with key lime mustard sauce, served with chef’s rice, black beans and vegetables 19.95

Island Steak

Char grilled 7 oz. sirloin strip steak served with vine ripe tomatoes and chef’s rice 17.95

BBQ Shrimp

Key West Pink Gold Shrimp wrapped in bacon, topped with monterey jack, cheddar cheese & bbq sauce. Served with chef’s rice and veggies 17.95

Pico de Gallo

With grilled mahi served over black beans and chef’s rice 18.95

Key West Shrimp Tempura

Jumbo shrimp dipped in tempura batter then deep-fried, served with chef’s rice, veggies & mango chutney 20.95

Coconut Fried Shrimp

Served with toasted coconut, chef’s rice, veggies & mango chutney 18.95


Served with french fries & cole slaw

Fried Key West Pink Shrimp 13.95

Fried Mahi Mahi 12.95

Fried Grouper 16.95

Fried Clam Strips 9.95

Fried Select Oysters Market $

Chicken Wings 11.95

Choice of mild, medium or hot sauce

Chicken Fingers 10.95


Served with coleslaw, pickle & french fries

Fried Oyster Po Boy

On a toasted hoagie roll with remoulade sauce, tomato &  banana peppers 13.95

Mahi Mahi Sandwich

Served on a toasted kaiser roll…Fried or Grilled 12.95, Blackened 13.95

Grouper Sandwich

Served on a toasted kaiser roll… Fried or Grilled 14.95, Blackened 15.95

Grilled Mojo Chicken Breast

Boneless and skinless  marinated in Cuban Mojo 9.95

California Chicken Sandwich

Grilled chicken breast topped with jack cheese, bacon, and guacamole on multigrain bread  12.95

The Island’s Cheese Steak

Thinly sliced sirloin topped with sautéed peppers, mushrooms, onions and cheddar cheese 12.95

French Dip

Tender slices of roast beef  on french bread with creamy horseradish sauce & au jus 12.95

Angus Beef Sirloin Burger


Add, American, Swiss, Monterey Jack, Blue Cheese, bacon, grilled onion,  or sautéed mushrooms .75 each

Veggie Burger

Served on a toasted kaiser roll 8.95

Lobster Sandwich

Coconut fried lobster tail served sourdough bread with lettuce, diced tomatoes and remoulade sauce Market $


Served with bread and choice of soup or salad

Petite Surf & Turf

4 oz. grilled filet mignon & half a Florida lobster stuffed with mango crabmeat stuffing, served with béarnaise sauce, drawn butter, new potatoes & sautéed vegetables 36.95

Surf & Turf

8 oz. grilled filet mignon & whole Florida lobster tail served with béarnaise sauce, drawn butter, new potatoes & sautéed vegetables 53.95

Filet Mignon

A  hand cut tender 8 oz. filet, grilled served with béarnaise sauce, new potatoes and sautéed vegetables 33.95

New York Strip

The big brother to Island steak, 12 oz. cut with all the fat trimmed out, seasoned & grilled to perfection. Served with new potatoes and sautéed vegetables 29.95

Add sautéed mushrooms to any of the above… $1.50


Served with bread and choice of soup or salad

Pasta Basilico

Vine ripe tomatoes, garlic olive oil, parmesan cheese & fresh basil over linguini 15.95 ~ With Chicken 18.95

Clams or Mussels Marinara

With our homemade marinara, served over linguini 17.95

White Clam Linguini

Little neck clams with olive oil, garlic & white wine 17.95

Shellfish Lover’s Pasta

A sauté of fresh shrimp, clams, mussels & scallops. Finished with fresh cream, lemon, sherry, fresh herbs and butter served over linguini 24.95

Key West Shrimp Fra Diavlo

Cajun spiced sautéed shrimp over linguini tossed with a spicy marinara sauce 22.95

Key West Shrimp Diane

Dusted in Cajun seasoning then sautéed with mushrooms, scallions, garlic, white wine & herb butter served over linguini 22.95

Key West Shrimp Scampi

Sautéed with white wine, butter, lemon scallion & lots of garlic tossed with linguini 22.95


Served with chef’s rice & sautéed vegetables, with bread and choice of soup or salad.

All Are Market $


For the purist, with lemon

Pan Seared

Lightly dusted in flour and sautéed with sherry, lemon & butter


Cajun seasoned


Cooked with sherry & fresh lemon


Dipped in  egg wash and sautéed in white wine & butter


Broiled in sherry & lemon juice, topped with roasted almond slices


Stuffed with mango crabmeat stuffed & topped with a key lime hollandaise sauce

Florida Lobster Tail

From our local waters, broiled or Francaise style


Strawberry Cheesecake

The real deal New York Midtown style. Thick & creamy topped with Strawberries & whipped cream 7.95

Deep Fried Key Lime Pie

Key Lime Pie deep fried crispy. Rolled in cinnamon sugar and drizzled with mango sauce. Served with whipped cream  7.95

Blueberry Pie

Baked right here… Fresh blueberries baked in a flaky pie crust. Topped with whipped cream  7.95

Ultimate Chocolate Cake

A house specialty baked on the premise, flourless, with two layers of chocolate served with whipped cream 9.95

…and of course

Key Lime Pie

You have to have it while in the Keys. Our recipe originated with us at Shuckers’ and is the perfect blend of sweet and tart has lasted through the years. Topped with whipped cream 5.95


French Fries 2.95

Beans and Rice 4.95

Basket of Artisan Bread 2.75

Sautéed Vegetables 4.50

Fried Plantains 4.50

Onion Rings 3.50

Sweet Potato Fries 3.95

Black Beans 2.50

Chef’s Rice 2.50

Garlic Bread 2.95

New Potatoes 2.95

Curly Fries 2.95


Hamburger & Fries 7.25
Cheeseburger & Fries 7.50
Grilled Cheese & Fries 7.00
Pasta & Sauce 7.25
Fish Fingers & Fries 8.25
Chicken Fingers & Fries 7.50
Hot Dog & Fries 7.50
Popcorn Shrimp & Fries 8.25